Sunday, November 26, 2023

When Does Judgement Begin? Sooner than you think... Matthew 25: 31-46

Pay special attention to today's text from Matthew's Gospel; perhaps you might want to just this once, take sermon notes. There will be a test at the end.

Like many, or perhaps even most Lutherans, I suppose, we don't think very often or very specifically about the glorious return of Christ for the final judgment. We believe in all these things. They're in the Bible. They're in the Creeds. They're in our hymns. So, they are present in our Sunday lives, but somewhere between Sunday, 11am, and Monday 6am, they stop shaping our daily lives.

This leaves us with a big question for today about the final judgment: when? When? By when I don't mean the year or the day or the hour or the moment of Christ’s return. All of that will certainly be important enough when it happens, but there's not a lot to say about that in the meantime, except that we don't know, we won't know, and we can't know.

The big question in the gospel appointed for this day is another kind of “when” question, when that some of you have wisely asked the last few weeks. That question is, when will all this get decided? When does the judgement stuff happen? When does the Lord make up His mind about who goes where and what happens to us? When is it decided whether the nations of the world belong in the ranks of the sheep or the goats?  The answer to this particular “when” question is not a secret, but it is really surprising. The answer to when is the final judgment is, “Right now.” Today. And that answer may surprise you.

Many people, including perhaps some of us, may sometimes suppose that it's all kind of up for grabs and to-be-determined until the end. But Jesus says that when he returns, He will judge based on things that will have already happened. That is stuff that people do right now, in fact. It's all rather surprising.

When we were kids, one of my siblings had a jack-in-the-box. You know, the kind that has this little clown doll on a spring and you push the clown down inside the box and close the lid. Then you turn the little crank and it plays this little song, “All around the cobbler’s bench…” And when you get to one place in the song, the same place every time, “Pop! Goes the weasel!” and the lid flies up and the clown popped out and it scared the bejeebers out of the kid. Even though every kid knows exactly when the stupid clown would pop up at the same place in the same stupid song over and over again, it still surprised the kid every time. The point is that just knowing when doesn't mean you won't be surprised.

That’s what Matthew means. Just knowing when doesn't mean it's not a surprise. These folks are standing there, sheep and goats, and are divided before the glorious throne of the Son of Man, and they hear Him speak blessing or judgment at the end of time. In both cases, for the sheep on the right and for the goats on his left, the basis for the judgment is the same. They have all, He says, done - or not done - some crucial acts of kindness and mercy to the Lord himself.  And both groups, those receiving His blessings and those being sent away, are surprised.

This is where they ask the big question for today, “When, Lord? When did we see you hungry or thirsty, or strange or needing clothes or sick or in prison? We don't remember any of that stuff about you. We're sure we would have remembered something important like that.” It's almost as if all of them, both the sheep and the goats, think there must be some mistake - maybe a wonderful mistake; maybe a terrible mistake - but there must be some mistake.

“Are you sure, Lord?,” protest the sheep. “I think I would have remembered if I'd ever had the chance to serve you personally. That surely would have been a big deal. Something to mark on the calendar and write in my diary. But all I can think of when I look back is all the ordinary stuff with all those ordinary people… just the same old, same old. Nothing important enough for You to bring up at an important time like this.”

On the other side of the aisle, there is also confusion and surprise. “Now… now wait, Lord, there must be some mistake. Of course, if there'd ever been anything I could do for You, you know, I wouldn't have hesitated a moment. But we never saw You. We never neglected any of the really important things that we did for You. We never let all the trivial stuff, or those minor interruptions distract us from focusing on you, Lord. When did we do this? When did we not do this?”

Then comes the kicker. It's a surprise, even though you know it's coming. Jesus and Matthew have set us up. It's as if we're in on it, and they - the nations - are not. You and I have heard it 100 times or more, and you're going to hear it some more, before you hear it from the Lord Himself. And still, it catches us off guard and makes us catch our breath every time.  The King will answer them truly, I say to you, “As you did it, or did not do it, to one of the least of these, my brethren, you did it, or not, to me.”

These words of Jesus are like a spotlight that shines with bright, blazing brilliance back through time, through our times, from the end of time. It shows us our day-to-day and mundane lives for what they truly are: service to Christ, or the refusal of such service. The beams of that light reveal the colors and the contours of what otherwise seems like the most normal drudgery and common labor. Well, it may be normal, but it's anything but common.

My first sentence, I said there was a test. These are the questions. Of course, I'm not sure I want all the little encounters and choices and decisions that make up my life to get loaded with that kind of significance. I'm not so sure that the everyday conduct of my life can bear the weight of that ultimate and decisive meaning. The truth is that I, and perhaps you too, live most often in the comfortable shadow-lands, where we test pretty well when we have time to prepare, but we’re not so good at keeping up with the daily homework of life with missing or incomplete assignments. Come to think of it, I probably count on much of what I do not actually mattering all that much in the end, one way or the other.

But it does matter in the end, one way or the other. What I do and don't do to the scruffy looking smelly guy that asked for money on the street matters. How you treat that annoying neighbor who plays her Taylor Swift CD's late at night and won't return your tools that he borrowed, it matters. The phone call we decided to put off to that guy we haven’t seen in months and years, it matters. Jesus, you see, injects Himself into the daily choices you and I make about humdrum moments and ordinary people even, or perhaps especially, the least of these. He shines an extraordinary light into our ordinary lives and interactions because it's not only the life and death necessities; it’s the seemingly little and regular stuff, too.

Can we hear the Lord saying, “I had an owie and you made it better.” “I lost my dog and you comforted me.” “I was exhausted after all day with the kids and you did the dishes and folded the laundry.” “I didn’t understand the assignment and you sat with me and encouraged me.” He adds eternal weight to the mundane duties of our daily vocation – the using of the gifts we talked about last week. The surprise is the answer to the “when” question. When do you serve Christ? When you are a faithful – not perfect, but faithful - husband, father, sister, mother, son, neighbor, teacher, student, friend. Because then, Jesus says, you do it to him.

What would it be like to live every single day as if eternity were riding on it? What would it mean if we encountered every other human being as if he or she were Jesus Christ himself in disguise? C.S. Lewis, whom you probably know from The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe, quoting John Dunn, posed the question. “What if this present moment was the world's last? Wouldn't it be a surprising life?”

The final judgment, my friends, is really going to happen. And a lot of people, maybe most people, are going to be really, really surprised. Many, of course, are going to be surprised that it happens at all, but according to the words of Jesus, they're going to be surprised also by the “when” of it all, not the date or the time of day, which will be a surprise of its own, but the “when” of all those moments that counts and are counted in the final analysis. When Lord? The sheep, the righteous, the blessed of the Father will be surprised. When the day feed the hungry Christ in disguise? When did they visit a sick Christ without knowing it? When did they take care of a needy Christ and not recognize him? The goats, those who have brought a curse down on their own heads, will also be surprised. How were they supposed to know that it all mattered?

And just one more little surprise: Jesus does tell His disciples – us - about this final judgment to make us consider carefully what we do now in the coming light of His return. He wants the certainty of His second coming and the assured secrecy of it to be connected with a mighty therefore to the way we conduct ourselves in the meantime. He wants us to be surprised, but surprised the way the sheep are surprised and not the way the goats are. But the whole picture, the big picture, of glorious judge, and sheep, and goats, and angels is also meant to comfort us in an altogether different way because there's somebody else in the picture there - somebody you can almost overlook, somebody you don't notice at first glance. They're up there. Beside the throne, kind of huddled around Jesus. “They're the ones,” He says, “these are My brothers and sisters.”

That congregation includes you and me, because we're Jesus disciples. His own blood removes all threat of punishment from us. His spirit sends us out as His messengers, and it matters to Him a lot how His messengers are treated. It matters to Him how His message is received. “He who receives you receives Me,” Jesus tells the disciples, “And he who receives Me receives the One who sent Me. And if anyone gives even a cup of cold water to one of these little ones, because he is My disciple, I tell you the truth, he will certainly not lose his reward. I’ll remember.”

Jesus sends His disciples out under His authority on His mission to make disciples of all nations. Gathered and divided before the throne the nations will be called to answer for how they treat the disciples. Not because we are big stuff in and of ourselves, but because of whose brothers and sisters we are. If something is done or not done to even the least of these brothers and sisters of His, it's done to Jesus Himself.

I think that guy may have been the one I bought dinner for at Jack in the Box. I think that might be the teacher who taught one of your children. I think that might be that very, very quiet woman or man at work. I think you might live with one of those least of these, my brethren. It might even have been you.

It is a matter of ultimate concern to Jesus: What becomes of you, His brothers and sisters; how it goes with you, whether you are fed, whether you are clothed, whether you were treated well, whether you were visited, whether you are cared for. He will ask about those things when he returns in glory. He will remember. Because He cares for you. Isn't that a surprise. Oh, and by the way: the test starts now.

No comments:

Post a Comment